A Roth conversion can’t be undone, so before the next one, get the plan in writing, year by year, and have someone who isn’t paid on your assets check that it covers your RMDs, your Medicare premiums, the years one of you is alone and what your heirs will owe. You can get that second opinion from a Roth conversion specialist like Q3 Advisors, a fee-only planner found through a network such as NAPFA, or a CPA who projects your taxes forward instead of only filing last year’s return.
When should you get a second opinion on a Roth conversion?
Get one when the advice you have is a verdict rather than a plan. Four signs it’s time:
- You got a yes or a no with no written analysis behind it. Kiplinger calls that “a red flag.”
- The plan converts a small amount each year “to stay in your bracket,” but nothing shows what happens to that bracket later.
- Your CPA advised against converting because it would raise your tax bill this year.
- Nobody has shown you what your spouse pays after one of you passes, or what your heirs owe on what’s left.
Your CPA may well be right that a smaller conversion means a smaller bill next April. A tax return looks back one year. A conversion plan has to look forward 20 to 40 years. We cover that split in why your CPA’s Roth conversion advice may fall short.
What should you bring to a Roth conversion second opinion?
Have these ready:
- Your last two federal tax returns, and your state return
- A current statement for every account, grouped by type: pre-tax (IRAs, 401(k)s, 403(b)s), Roth and taxable
- Your Social Security estimates and any pension amounts, with the age each one starts
- The current recommendation in writing: how much to convert, in which years
- Your beneficiary designations, and whom you’d like the money to reach
- Any Medicare premium notice that included an income-related surcharge
- Form 8606, if you’ve ever made nondeductible IRA contributions
If you can’t find a written recommendation to bring, that’s your answer: you don’t have a plan yet, just a suggestion.
What should a written Roth conversion plan show?
A plan is a schedule you can read, not a sentence. Check that it has each of these, with your own numbers in it.
A row for every year, with the lifetime total. It should run from this year through your RMD years and the years after, and show the tax each year, plus the total over your lifetime and your heirs’. A plan that only compares this year’s bill with and without a conversion doesn’t answer your real question: what you pay over a lifetime.
Your RMDs, from the right age. RMDs start at 73 if you were born from 1951 through 1958, and at 75 if you were born in 1960 or later. (Treasury hasn’t settled the age for people born in 1959.) The plan should project your pre-tax balance to that age and show each year’s forced withdrawal.
The bracket each conversion fills. In 2026, for a married couple filing jointly, the 22% bracket ends at $211,400 of taxable income and the 24% bracket ends at $403,550. The plan should show your taxable income with each conversion against those lines, and say why it stops where it does.
Your Medicare premiums two years later. Medicare sets each year’s Part B and Part D surcharges from your income two years earlier. For 2026 premiums, the first surcharge starts at 2024 income above $218,000 for a joint return and $109,000 for a single one. For 2027, those lines rise to $224,000 and $112,000. A good plan shows each conversion year’s income next to the premium year it sets, and decides on purpose whether crossing a line is worth it.
The years one of you is alone. After the year a spouse passes, the survivor usually files single. In 2026 the single 24% bracket ends at $201,775, half the joint line, and the first Medicare surcharge line halves too. The same income can land one or two brackets higher. A plan that only models the two of you together misses the years that often cost the most. More on this in the widow’s penalty in 2026.
What your heirs owe. Most non-spouse heirs must empty an inherited IRA by the end of the 10th year after the owner’s death, and every traditional IRA dollar they take out is ordinary income on top of their own pay. The plan should show the balance you’re likely to leave and the bracket it would hit for them. See the three versions of the 10-year rule.
Where the tax money comes from. Paying the conversion tax from outside cash leaves more in the Roth than paying it from the IRA. The plan should say which, and count your state’s tax. Each conversion also starts its own five-year period for penalty purposes, and if you have nondeductible IRA contributions, Form 8606 decides how much of each conversion is taxable.
The years a Roth conversion plan has to show: a couple both born in 1960
- 2026, age 66: you convertThe converted amount is taxable income this year, at the bracket it reaches.
- 2028, age 68: Medicare premiumsYour 2028 Part B and Part D premiums are set by your 2026 income.
- 2035, age 75: RMDs beginForced withdrawals start from whatever pre-tax balance is left.
- After one of you passes: single bracketsThe survivor’s 24% bracket ends at $201,775 instead of $403,550 (2026 figures).
- After you both pass: your heirs’ 10 yearsMost heirs must empty an inherited IRA by the end of the 10th year.
The biggest Roth conversion mistake is deciding on a one-year view. A conversion made after 2017 can’t be recharacterized back to a traditional IRA, so whatever the plan missed, you live with.
How does your plan compare with the plans we build?
Across 918 active Rothology® plans started in 2026 (as of Nov 12, 2026), the median plan converts $260,000 a year, and the middle half convert between $170,000 and $380,000. The median plan converts over 6 years, and the middle half over 5 to 8. In a typical conversion year, 450 of 914 plans (49%) reach the 32% bracket or higher, and only 117 (13%) stay at 22% or lower.
These describe plans we’ve built, not a target for yours. But if your IRA is in the millions and your plan stops at 22% or 24% because that’s where it always stops, ask to see the projection behind that line. More on the amount in how much to convert to a Roth each year.
What a written conversion schedule looks like
| Year | Convert | Taxable | Bracket | Premiums |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $260,000 | $350,000 | 24% | 2028 |
| 2027 | $260,000 | $350,000 | 24% | 2029 |
| 2028 | $260,000 | $350,000 | 24% | 2030 |
| 2029 | $260,000 | $350,000 | 24% | 2031 |
| 2030 | $260,000 | $350,000 | 24% | 2032 |
| 2031 | $260,000 | $350,000 | 24% | 2033 |
| 2035 | RMDs begin at 75 | |||
Where can you get a second opinion on your Roth conversion plan?
Three things separate the options: how the reviewer is paid, whether you get a written year-by-year schedule, and whether you have to move your money.
Q3 Advisors: a Rothology® plan
Our team of CFP® professionals does Roth conversion planning all day, for more than 4,000 families so far. We build you a written, year-by-year conversion schedule with Medicare premium analysis and federal and state tax projections, and review it with you every year for the life of the plan. It typically takes 2 to 4 weeks. You don’t have to move your portfolio or leave your advisor: we work alongside them and your CPA. It’s a one-time flat consulting fee: $11,000 for Premier and $8,100 for Legacy. We don’t charge a percentage of your assets. If we can’t help you avoid at least $500,000 in taxes, we’ll refund the full consulting fee.* Clients typically have $1 million or more in pre-tax accounts; $750,000 is the qualifying floor. See what a Rothology plan includes.
*Must be pre-qualified by one of our Roth conversion advisors.
A fee-only planner, found through a network. Several networks list planners who charge for advice rather than earning commissions:
- NAPFA, an association of fee-only advisors, with a Find an Advisor directory
- Garrett Planning Network, whose members offer planning on an hourly, as-needed basis
- XY Planning Network, whose fee-only members offer planning for a monthly subscription fee
- Advice-Only Network, planners who charge a flat or hourly fee for advice and don’t take commissions
- Flat Fee Advisors, a directory of fee-only advisors who charge a fixed fee; listed advisors may pay a membership fee to be included
A directory lists planners; it doesn’t review your plan. Depth on Roth conversion math varies from planner to planner, so before you pay, ask for a sample year-by-year schedule like the one above and the fee in writing.
A CPA or enrolled agent who projects. Some tax professionals run multi-year projections as well as filing returns. Ask for one that covers your RMD years, the surviving-spouse years and your heirs.
A free review from a firm paid on your assets. Many firms offer one. Ask how they’re paid and whether the recommendation depends on moving your money to them.
How do you check who’s reviewing your plan?
Look up any adviser or firm before you hand over your statements:
- The SEC’s Investment Adviser Public Disclosure site (adviserinfo.sec.gov) and FINRA BrokerCheck show an adviser’s and a firm’s record.
- CFP Board’s verify tool, at cfp.net/verify, confirms a CFP® certification.
- Form CRS is the firm’s short relationship summary for clients. The Form ADV Part 2 brochure lays out the adviser’s fees, conflicts of interest and disciplinary information in plain English.
Under federal law, a registered investment adviser, Q3 Advisors included, is a fiduciary. For the questions to ask about fees, see what a flat fee should cover, and for typical prices, how much a financial advisor costs.
If you’re still deciding whether converting makes sense at all, start with the pros and cons of a Roth conversion, or read Craig Wear’s free book, Paying the Piper.