Roth Conversion Pros and Cons for a $1M+ IRA

A card listing the pros and cons of a Roth conversion: no RMDs on the Roth, tax-free for heirs and you pick the rate, against a tax bill this year, higher Medicare premiums later and no undo

Written by Craig Wear, CFP®, founder of Q3 Advisors

A Roth conversion trades a tax bill this year for money that required minimum distributions (RMDs) can never force out, and that comes out tax-free for you and your heirs. With $1 million or more in pre-tax accounts, which side wins comes down to one comparison: the rate you pay on converted dollars now against the rate the same dollars face later, in RMD years, as a widowed spouse filing single, and in your heirs’ 10-year window. When later is higher, the pros win. When it’s lower, the cons do.

Roth conversion pros and cons at a glance

Pro or con What it means with a $1M+ IRA
Pro: no RMDs on the Roth Money you convert stops feeding the RMDs that start at 73 or 75 and grow with the balance
Pro: tax-free to your heirs Heirs still empty most inherited accounts within 10 years, but Roth withdrawals generally come out tax-free
Pro: you pick the rate You fill a bracket on purpose in your lower-income years instead of letting RMDs and single filing set it
Con: the tax bill now Every converted dollar is ordinary income this year, on top of everything else you earn
Con: Medicare premiums Income over an IRMAA line raises Part B and Part D premiums, generally two years later
Con: no undo A conversion can’t be reversed, even if the market drops the next week

Pros of a Roth conversion

Your Roth never forces a withdrawal

As the original owner of a Roth IRA, you don’t have to take distributions at any age. Your traditional IRA is different: RMDs begin at 73 if you were born from 1951 through 1958, and at 75 if you were born in 1960 or later. (Treasury hasn’t settled the age for people born in 1959.) A large IRA that keeps growing until then turns into large forced withdrawals, taxed at whatever your rate is in those years. Every dollar you convert first is a dollar those RMDs can’t reach. You can check what the IRS factors would require with the 2026 Uniform Lifetime Table.

You choose the rate and the year

If you never convert, the IRS still collects, on its schedule and at its rate. Converting lets you fill your lower brackets at a known rate in your lowest-income years, usually after paychecks stop and before RMDs start. That control is the real pro.

More room under the Medicare and Social Security lines later

Roth withdrawals don’t count as income the way RMDs do. A smaller pre-tax balance means smaller RMDs. That can keep you under IRMAA lines in the years they’d otherwise push you over. It also keeps more of your Social Security out of tax. Up to 85% of benefits can be taxable once half your benefits plus all your other income passes $34,000 for a single filer or $44,000 for a married couple filing jointly.

Cons of a Roth conversion

How much tax will I pay on a $100,000 Roth conversion?

A conversion is taxed as income in the year you make it, so the bill turns on where your other income already sits. Using the 2026 federal brackets for a couple filing jointly:

Taxable income before converting Federal tax on a $100,000 conversion Bracket the conversion lands in
$100,800 $22,000 All 22%
$211,400 $24,000 All 24%
$350,000 $27,716 $53,550 at 24%, $46,450 at 32%

Hypothetical illustration. Not a guarantee of future results. Federal income tax only, before state tax and any Medicare or Social Security effects. For a full walk-through, see how much tax you’ll pay on a Roth conversion.

Medicare premiums can rise two years later

Medicare’s income-related surcharge (IRMAA) looks back. For 2026, Social Security generally uses your 2024 tax return, so a conversion you make in 2026 can show up in your 2028 premiums. In 2026 the first line is $218,000 of modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) for a married couple filing jointly and $109,000 for a single filer, and crossing it adds $81.20 a month to each person’s Part B premium. For 2027 the first line rises to $224,000 and $112,000. Each line is a cliff: one dollar over it moves you into the next tier. Our IRMAA brackets page has every tier.

You can’t undo it

Since 2018, a conversion can’t be recharacterized back to a traditional IRA. If the market drops the week after you convert, you still owe tax on the amount you moved. It’s one more reason to convert a large IRA in pieces over several years, not all at once.

What is the Roth conversion 5-year rule?

There are two clocks. Each conversion has its own 5-year clock, and taking converted money out before it runs can cost a 10% additional tax if you’re under 59½. Tax-free earnings need 5 years from your first Roth tax year and a qualifying event such as turning 59½. For most retirees converting after 60, neither clock is the deciding con. Our page on the 5-year rule for Roth conversions covers the details.

The RMD comes first

There’s no income limit on conversions, only on direct Roth contributions. But once RMDs start, you can’t convert that year’s RMD. You take it, pay tax on it, and only then convert more.

Roth conversion at 70: RMDs and 2026 tax brackets

If you turn 70 in 2026, you were born in 1956, so your RMDs start at 73. That leaves about three years, 2026 through 2028, to convert before forced withdrawals start adding to your income. You can keep converting after that, but every year’s RMD comes on top. Three years is a short window for a big balance. The real question isn’t whether to convert. It’s how much, each year.

Our own plans show how big those yearly conversions get. Across 914 active Rothology® plans started in 2026 (as of November 12, 2026), about half, 450 of 914, reach the 32% bracket or higher in a typical conversion year.

The federal bracket 914 Rothology plans reach in a typical conversion year

22% or lower117 plans (13%)
22% or lower: 117 plans, 13%
24%347 plans (38%)
24%: 347 plans, 38%
32%183 plans (20%)
32%: 183 plans, 20%
35%172 plans (19%)
35%: 172 plans, 19%
37%95 plans (10%)
37%: 95 plans, 10%
Across 914 active Rothology plans started in 2026, as of Nov 12, 2026 (four plans have no bracket recorded). The bracket is the one a plan’s ordinary income reaches in a typical conversion year. Aggregates of active plans, not finished plans and not a promise of any result.

So for a large IRA, “stay in a low bracket” isn’t the plan. Paying 24% or 32% now makes sense when RMDs, a surviving spouse or your heirs would otherwise pay 32% or more on the same dollars. Across the 918 active plans, the median converts $260,000 a year over 6 years. For how to size each year, see how much to convert to a Roth.

The widow’s tax penalty and Roth conversions

A surviving spouse can file jointly for the year of death. After that, they file single, unless a dependent child qualifies them as a qualifying surviving spouse for two more years. The survivor can take over the IRA and its RMDs. Most of the income stays. The brackets and the IRMAA line shrink.

The same $200,000 of income, filed jointly and filed single, 2026

10% and 12% brackets22% bracket24% bracket32% bracketFirst IRMAA line

Married filing jointly: $200,000 is in the 22% bracket

Married filing jointly, 2026: taxable income from $100,800 to $211,400 is in the 22% bracket, so $200,000 is taxed at 22%; the first IRMAA line is $218,000 of MAGI.
IRMAA line
$218,000

Single, after a spouse passes: $200,000 is in the 24% bracket

Single, 2026: the 22% bracket ends at $105,700 and the 24% bracket runs to $201,775, so $200,000 is taxed at 24%; the first IRMAA line is $109,000 of MAGI.
IRMAA line
$109,000
2026 federal brackets from IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-32 (taxable income) and the 2026 first IRMAA line from Social Security (MAGI). Hypothetical illustration. Not a guarantee of future results.

Same $200,000 of taxable income: 22% filed jointly, 24% filed single, and the first IRMAA line halves, from $218,000 to $109,000. Converting while you still file jointly fills the wider joint brackets with dollars that would otherwise reach the survivor at single rates. More on this in the widow’s penalty in 2026.

Roth conversions and your heirs’ 10-year rule

Most non-spouse heirs have to empty an inherited IRA by the end of the 10th year after your death. The exceptions are a surviving spouse, a minor child, someone disabled or chronically ill, and someone not more than 10 years younger than you. With a traditional IRA, every dollar your heirs withdraw in those 10 years is ordinary income, stacked on top of their own pay. An inherited Roth follows the same timing rules, but its withdrawals generally come out tax-free. The details are in the three versions of the inherited IRA 10-year rule.

Run the numbers on a $2 million IRA. Emptied over 10 years, it adds an average of $200,000 a year to an heir’s income, before any growth, on top of what they already earn. If your kids inherit in their peak earning years, your traditional IRA is taxed at their top rate, not yours.

When a Roth conversion isn’t worth it

As the planning site Kitces.com puts it, “If the funds can be taxed at a lower rate upon withdrawal in the future, don’t convert them.” If the rates are equal, you come out even, and a conversion big enough to jump a bracket “can negate or even reverse the tax benefits.” A peer-reviewed study in the Journal of Financial Planning (September 2024) found conversions can lose money, with losses that grow with the rate gap and a payoff that may not be complete until 20 or 30 years have passed.

In practice, a conversion is wrong in a few specific situations: you’re under 59½ with no outside cash to pay the tax; you’re past your mid-70s with no legacy goal; your IRA is small enough that future RMDs never lift your bracket, IRMAA tier or Social Security taxation; or your IRA sits inside an annuity the carrier converts only in full. If you plan to leave the IRA to charity, or your heirs will truly be in a lower bracket than you, leaving the traditional IRA can also come out ahead. Test that assumption with real numbers: withdrawals squeezed into 10 years can lift an heir into a higher bracket than their pay alone would. Our page on when Roth conversions are wrong goes through each case.

How to weigh the pros and cons for your IRA

Compare the rate you’d pay on converted dollars this year against four later rates:

  • Your rate in RMD years, at 73 or 75, with the balance you’ll have by then
  • Your spouse’s rate filing single, with the single IRMAA line
  • Your heirs’ rate while they empty the account within 10 years
  • The IRMAA tier your income lands in two years after each conversion

Then decide where the tax money comes from. Paying it from the IRA shrinks what reaches the Roth, and under 59½ it can add a penalty. The biggest mistake is guessing in either direction: converting everything in one year, or never converting because the bill looks big. A break-even analysis over your own years is a cleaner way to decide than any rule of thumb.

That analysis is what a Rothology plan is. It’s a one-time flat consulting fee for your Roth conversion plan, built by CFP® professionals, with annual reviews for the life of the plan: $11,000 for Premier and $8,100 for Legacy. We don’t charge a percentage of your assets, and we coordinate with your existing advisors. Clients typically have $1 million or more in pre-tax accounts; $750,000 is the qualifying floor. If we can’t help you avoid at least $500,000 in taxes, we’ll refund the full consulting fee.* See what a Rothology plan includes.

*Must be pre-qualified by one of our Roth conversion advisors.

This content is educational and is not individualized investment, tax, or legal advice. Q3 Advisors, LLC is an investment adviser registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission; registration does not imply a certain level of skill or training. Worked examples are hypothetical illustrations, not a guarantee of future results. Plan figures are aggregates of active Rothology plans started in 2026, as of Nov 12, 2026.
Craig Wear Craig Wear
Helping IRA Millionaires save $1 million (or more) in unnecessary taxes

Is a Roth Conversion Right for You?

Get a personalized strategy from the firm that’s saved clients $9 billion in projected taxes

  • 2,400+ families guided through conversions
  • $9B in tax avoidance
  • Built for $1M+ IRAs

no obligation. 45-minute consultation